Below is the complete article
How do you choose one song to hold closest to your heart when nearly every song carries a piece of your life? For ABBA, that question may be almost impossible to answer. Across decades of extraordinary music, Agnetha Fältskog, Björn Ulvaeus, Benny Andersson, and Anni-Frid Lyngstad created songs that became deeply personal to millions of listeners. Yet when it comes to choosing the one ABBA song that means more than all the others, there has never been a simple, permanent answer shared by all four members.
Perhaps that is because ABBA’s music was never just a collection of hits. It became a diary of four lives changing together.
Think of “Waterloo.” The song represents the explosion that changed everything. After winning the Eurovision Song Contest in 1974, ABBA suddenly stepped onto an international stage. The bright costumes, irresistible melody, and infectious energy announced that something new had arrived from Sweden. For the members, “Waterloo” could never simply be another successful record. It was the doorway through which they entered music history.
But how could they choose “Waterloo” over “Dancing Queen”?
Released in 1976, “Dancing Queen” became one of ABBA’s defining recordings and eventually their only No. 1 single on the U.S. Billboard Hot 100. Its shimmering arrangement and joyous rhythm made it sound almost weightless. Decades later, the opening notes can still transform a room. For countless listeners, “Dancing Queen” represents youth, freedom, celebration, and the fleeting beauty of feeling completely alive.
Then there are the songs that carry something darker.
“The Winner Takes It All” remains perhaps the clearest example of how ABBA could transform private emotional pain into universal art. Released after the breakdown of Agnetha and Björn’s marriage, the song naturally became associated with their separation, even though Björn has explained that it should not be read as a literal autobiography. Agnetha’s extraordinary vocal performance gives the song its devastating emotional power. She does not merely sing about losing love; she makes the listener feel what it is like to stand helplessly while something once precious disappears.
Could a song carrying such complicated memories ever comfortably be called a “favorite”?
That may be the heart of the question.
ABBA’s greatest songs represent different chapters of their lives. “Mamma Mia” carries the irresistible confidence of their rise. “Knowing Me, Knowing You” sounds like the painful realization that love sometimes cannot be saved. “Chiquitita” offers tenderness and consolation. “Super Trouper” captures the strange loneliness that can exist beneath the lights of fame. “One of Us” feels like regret arriving after it is already too late.
And then there is “The Day Before You Came,” one of the group’s most haunting later recordings. Instead of the dazzling optimism associated with early ABBA, it presents an ordinary life filled with routine, loneliness, and subtle emotional emptiness. Its restrained atmosphere reveals just how far the group had traveled musically and emotionally.
That diversity helps explain why identifying one definitive favorite is so difficult. Benny might naturally think about composition and arrangement differently from Björn, whose relationship with the songs is closely connected to lyrics and storytelling. Agnetha and Frida, meanwhile, gave those words their emotional identities through voices that could make joy sparkle and heartbreak feel almost unbearably intimate.
Their relationship with the catalog may also change with time. A song connected with painful memories at one stage of life can become beautiful decades later. A massive hit may be admired for what it achieved, while a quieter album track may carry a more private emotional significance.
When ABBA Voyage opened in London in 2022, their music was no longer simply nostalgia. Younger listeners were discovering these songs as though they had just been released. “Dancing Queen,” “Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!,” “Lay All Your Love on Me,” and “The Winner Takes It All” found new audiences who brought their own stories to them.
Maybe that is the most fascinating part of ABBA’s legacy. The members created the songs, but eventually those songs stopped belonging only to them.
One listener hears “Dancing Queen” and remembers being seventeen. Another hears “The Winner Takes It All” and remembers the person they could not keep. Someone else hears “Chiquitita” and thinks of the friend who stayed beside them during their darkest days.
For ABBA, choosing just one song could mean choosing one memory, one relationship, one triumph, or one heartbreak above an entire lifetime.
And perhaps some songs are simply too deeply woven into a life to ever be ranked against one another.
