Below is the complete article
Some songs bring back a memory. Others reopen a wound—and for Benny Andersson, one chapter of ABBA’s music has become inseparable from the painful period when four people who once seemed unbreakable were quietly drifting apart.
For millions of listeners, ABBA’s songs are filled with glitter, unforgettable melodies, and the strange magic of hearing four very different personalities become one. But behind the polished harmonies were two marriages, two divorces, and four people trying to continue working together while their private lives were changing dramatically.
That is why stories about a song Benny supposedly finds difficult to revisit feel so powerful. Yet one important distinction should be made: there is no well-established public interview in which Benny definitively names one specific ABBA song and says he can never listen to it because of a single night that permanently changed the group. The idea works best as an emotional interpretation of ABBA’s final years rather than a confirmed confession.
And the truth behind that period is already heartbreaking enough.
By the beginning of the 1980s, ABBA was no longer the same group that had celebrated victory at Eurovision with “Waterloo.” Agnetha Fältskog and Björn Ulvaeus had divorced. Then Benny Andersson and Anni-Frid “Frida” Lyngstad separated as well.
They continued recording together, which required an extraordinary emotional discipline.
Imagine entering a studio with someone who had once been your husband or wife. The microphones are waiting. The melody is beautiful. The lyrics speak of loneliness, regret, or goodbye. Then the red recording light comes on, and somehow you are expected to turn private pain into perfect pop music.
Few songs capture that contradiction more hauntingly than “The Winner Takes It All.”
Released in 1980, the song was written primarily by Björn, but Agnetha’s performance gave it devastating emotional weight. Although Björn has resisted treating the lyrics as a literal account of their divorce, listeners inevitably connected the song to the collapse of their marriage.
The result was something almost uncomfortable in its intimacy.
Agnetha was not simply singing about losing someone. She was singing words written by the man she had loved, married, built a family with, and then separated from.
Benny’s piano helped carry that emotion.
That is the strange tragedy at the center of late-period ABBA: their personal relationships were breaking while their ability to create emotionally powerful music remained astonishingly intact.
Songs such as “When All Is Said and Done” made the boundary between art and life feel even thinner. Recorded after Benny and Frida’s relationship had ended, it carried the emotional atmosphere of two people accepting that something important was over.
The four members could still stand in the same studio.
They could still harmonize.
They could still create something beautiful.
But they could not return to who they had been.
That may be why certain ABBA recordings feel different when heard today. Beneath the immaculate production, there is sometimes a sense of people saying goodbye without actually using the word.
Eventually, the group stopped working together after 1982. There was no single explosive public breakup comparable to the dramatic endings of some famous bands. Instead, ABBA seemed to fade into separate lives.
And perhaps that quietness made it more painful.
There was no villain. No single betrayal that explained everything. Life had simply changed them.
Decades later, Benny, Björn, Agnetha, and Frida would reunite musically for Voyage, proving that affection and creative connection had survived the years. But reunion does not erase memory.
A melody can still transport someone back to a studio, a conversation, a look across the room—or the realization that an era is ending.
For fans, an ABBA song may last four minutes.
For the people who created it, those four minutes can contain an entire lifetime.
